Moana 2 has finally arrived in theaters and there’s one thing both critics and fans can agree on that is VERY different from its predecessor. Auliʻi Cravalho returns to voice Moana, and Dwayne Johnson (The Rock) is back as Maui, so it’s not that. What really fell off this time around was the music of Moana 2. It was fairly obvious to anyone who saw the original that Lin-Manuel Miranda was not involved this time around and that was a huge mistake by Disney. You could tell by how unoriginal and boring the new tracks for Moana 2 were that something was just off about the sequel. Unlike the original which featured memorable songs like “How Far I’ll Go” and “You’re Welcome,” the sequel’s soundtrack has nothing notable on it and has been universally criticized for being unremarkable and underwhelming. The movie is still good enough (not great) on its own so it’s worth a watch, but it could have been so much better with LMM.
The first Moana had a great story that was taken to the stratosphere by one of the best soundtracks Disney has ever put out; much like what we saw with Encanto (another Lin-Manuel Miranda work). His absence in Moana 2 left a noticeable gap in the musical quality and the overall appeal of the film. It will likely knock the numbers down a peg as many reviews for Moana 2 point to a lack of desire to see the movie again (a critical component of a successful Disney flick).
Without Miranda’s unique touch, Moana 2 struggles to capture the magic and emotional connection that made the original film beloved by audiences.
The Shore Seems Far: Did “Moana 2” Miss the Boat Without Lin-Manuel Miranda?
It’s true that many reviews of “Moana 2” are less positive than those for the original “Moana.” Many people who saw the movie feel it is not as good as the first one. One big difference between the two movies is that Lin-Manuel Miranda did not work on the music for “Moana 2.” He wrote all the music for the original “Moana.”
Some reviews say that “Moana 2” is still a fun movie for kids. But, they also say that the story is not as good as the first movie. The characters are not as interesting. This may be because Lin-Manuel Miranda did not help write the music.
Lin-Manuel Miranda is famous for writing music for movies and plays. He wrote the music for “Hamilton,” a very popular Broadway show. His music is often catchy and helps tell the story.
In the first “Moana” movie, the music was a big part of why people liked it so much. The songs were fun to listen to. They also helped people understand the characters and the story.
Some people think that “Moana 2” did not have the same magic without Lin-Manuel Miranda’s music. The new music may not be as memorable. It may not help the story as much as the music in the first movie.
| Movie | Composer | Rotten Tomatoes Score |
|---|---|---|
| Moana | Lin-Manuel Miranda | 96% |
| Moana 2 | Various | 69% |
It’s important to remember that these are just opinions. Some people may like the music in “Moana 2.” But, many people agree that the music in the first movie was special. It will be interesting to see if Disney asks Lin-Manuel Miranda to work on any future “Moana” movies.
Why Music Matters in Movies
Music can make a movie better in many ways. It can make you feel happy or sad. It can help you understand the characters. It can even help you remember the story better.
Think about some of your favorite movies. Do they have good music? Music can make a big difference in how much you enjoy a movie.
In children’s movies, music is even more important. Kids may enjoy a movie more if it has catchy songs. They may remember the movie better if the music is good.
Lin-Manuel Miranda is very good at writing music for movies. He knows how to make music that is fun to listen to. He also knows how to use music to help tell a story.
Maybe Disney will ask Lin-Manuel Miranda to work on future “Moana” movies. If they do, maybe those movies will be even better!
Moana 2 Review
“Moana 2” returns to the beautiful island world of Motunui with breathtaking animation and familiar characters. While it may not reach the same heights as its predecessor, this sequel offers an enjoyable journey with some new sights along the way. As expected from Disney, the animation is stunning. The ocean is depicted in exquisite detail, both captivating and intimidating in its vastness. From shimmering coral reefs to the fury of storms, the visuals are a feast for the eyes.
However, “Moana 2” falters in its narrative. The story feels somewhat predictable and lacks the emotional depth and originality of the first film. The new characters introduced, while charming, don’t quite capture the same magic as Maui or Pua. The absence of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s musical genius is also noticeable. Although the new songs are pleasant, they lack the memorable hooks and emotional resonance of the original soundtrack.
Overall, “Moana 2” feels safe—like a comfortable return to a familiar world rather than a bold exploration of new territory. Despite its shortcomings, the film remains enjoyable, particularly for younger audiences. It delivers a positive message about courage, friendship, and environmental responsibility. For those seeking a cinematic escape with beautiful visuals and an uplifting story, “Moana 2” offers a decent, if not entirely memorable, experience.
Exploring More Polynesian Tales
If you enjoyed the world of “Moana,” you might be interested in exploring other stories from Polynesian cultures. Many beautiful myths and legends from these islands are waiting to be discovered.
- “The Polynesian Pantheon:” Dive into the rich mythology of the Pacific Islands, with its fascinating gods and goddesses like Maui, Tangaroa, and Pele.
- “Navigating the Pacific:” Learn about the incredible seafaring skills of the Polynesian people and their voyages across vast oceans.
- “Polynesian Art and Culture:” Discover the unique artistic traditions of Polynesia, from intricate carvings to beautiful dances and music.
There are many books, documentaries, and online resources available to help you learn more about this fascinating region and its rich cultural heritage.
Key Takeaways
- Moana 2’s music falls short of the original due to Lin-Manuel Miranda’s absence
- The sequel’s visuals impress, but the songs fail to match the first film’s quality
- Critics emphasize the impact of strong musical numbers on Disney animations’ success
Impact of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Absence on Moana 2
Lin-Manuel Miranda’s departure from Moana 2 has left a noticeable gap in the film’s musical and storytelling elements. The change in composers has altered the sequel’s tone and emotional resonance.
Comparison of Musical Scores
The musical landscape of Moana 2 differs significantly from its predecessor. Abigail Barlow and Emily Bear, a Grammy-winning duo, have taken over songwriting duties. Their compositions lack the signature style that Miranda brought to the original film.
Critics have noted that the new songs feel less impactful and emotionally charged. The absence of Miranda’s unique blend of musical theater and Polynesian influences is apparent. Some viewers find the soundtrack less memorable compared to the original’s chart-topping hits.
Barlow and Bear’s work represents a fresh approach to Disney’s musical formula. As the first female composer team for a Disney animated feature, they bring a new perspective to the score.
Influence on Storytelling and Character Development
Miranda’s absence affects more than just the music. His contributions to the original Moana extended to character development and plot progression through song.
The sequel’s storytelling relies less on musical numbers to advance the narrative. This shift changes the pacing and emotional beats of the film. Characters may not express themselves as vividly through song as they did in the first movie.
Without Miranda’s input, the integration of Polynesian culture into the story may be less nuanced. His collaboration with Opetaia Foa’i in the original film added authenticity to the cultural representation.
The new creative team faces the challenge of maintaining the adventurous spirit and charm of the original characters. They must find new ways to convey the depth of emotions and cultural themes that Miranda’s lyrics expertly captured.
Audience Reception and Critical Analysis
Early reactions to Moana 2 are largely positive, with praise for its visuals and storytelling. Critics and fans have noted the absence of Lin-Manuel Miranda‘s songwriting, sparking discussions about the sequel’s musical direction.
Review Aggregator Insights
Rotten Tomatoes shows a strong initial score for Moana 2. Critics highlight the film’s stunning animation and emotional depth. Many reviewers compare it favorably to other recent Disney animated sequels. Some note that while the new songs are catchy, they lack the iconic feel of the original soundtrack.
The sequel’s expanded mythology and character development receive particular praise. Critics applaud the growth of Moana and Maui’s relationship. Several reviews mention the mid-credits scene as a highlight, generating excitement for potential future installments.
Fan Expectations and Box Office Implications
Disney fans express mixed feelings about Lin-Manuel Miranda’s absence. Some worry the sequel won’t capture the original’s musical magic. Others are eager to hear fresh voices in the soundtrack.
Box office predictions remain optimistic. The first film’s success and Dwayne Johnson’s star power are key factors. Industry analysts expect strong performances in both domestic and international markets.
Family audiences are likely to drive ticket sales during the Thanksgiving holiday. The film’s release on Disney+ is anticipated to boost its long-term popularity. Social media buzz indicates high interest among kids and adults alike.
Frequently Asked Questions
Lin-Manuel Miranda’s absence from Moana 2 has sparked discussions about its impact on the film’s soundtrack and creative direction. Critics and fans have shared their thoughts on the musical offerings and storyline of the sequel.
What impact did Lin-Manuel Miranda’s absence have on Moana 2?
Lin-Manuel Miranda’s absence led to changes in the musical landscape of Moana 2. His unique style and songwriting contributions were missing from the sequel. This shift prompted discussions among fans and critics about the soundtrack’s direction.
How has the soundtrack of Moana 2 been received in comparison to the original?
Early reviews suggest the soundtrack of Moana 2 differs from its predecessor. Some critics noted the change in musical style. The absence of Miranda’s signature sound was apparent to those familiar with the first film’s songs.
Can we expect a different creative direction in Moana 2 without Lin-Manuel Miranda?
Moana 2 took a new creative approach without Miranda’s involvement. The film’s musical direction evolved, reflecting the input of new composers and songwriters. This change allowed for fresh perspectives in storytelling and character development through music.
What are the critiques saying about the storyline and music of Moana 2?
Critics have shared mixed reactions to Moana 2’s storyline and music. Some praised the film’s continuation of Moana’s journey. Others felt the absence of Miranda’s musical touch affected the overall experience.
Which artists contributed to the Moana 2 soundtrack?
New artists and composers stepped in to create the soundtrack for Moana 2. While specific names have not been widely publicized, the film features a mix of established and emerging talent. These contributors brought their own styles to the musical landscape of Moana’s world.
How does Moana 2 differ from the first film in terms of cultural representation?
Moana 2 continues to showcase Polynesian culture and traditions. The sequel builds upon the foundation laid by the first film. It explores new aspects of Pacific Island heritage and expands on themes of identity and community.
